In Terry Pratchett's delightful "Diskworld" series, there is a entrepreneur of dubious ethics who appears just at the right moment to make a sale, whether of his famous -- if questionable -- pies, or more exotic wares. His pitch for his ostensibly cheap goods is that "I'm cutting me own throat," earning him the name "Cut Me Own Throat Dibbler."
The Bear figures many of his readers are traditionalists. He has nonetheless decided to cut his own throat, bite the hand that reads him, and spit into the wind of prevailing opinion by explaining why he is not a traditionalist.
First of all, this does not mean he has anything against traditionalists, or the Vetus Ordo. The Bear is familiar with the reasons the Vetus Ordo is symbolically superior to the Novus Ordo, and agrees with them. Traditionalists can be counted on to be well-catechized, fervent and philoprogenetive, all qualities much admired by the Bear. What traditionalists believe, the Bear probably believes. The Bear is glad they exist.
On the other hand, the average Novus Ordo parish is likely to be a mixed bag of clueless pewsitters, bad music and irreverent celebration that at best still has the priest facing the wrong way for a sacrifice, and offers the temptation for him to put on a show for the audience. It was probably a bad idea, and is certainly ripe for abuse. There is no need to rehearse the Novus Ordo's deficiencies for the Bear, because he can do so as well as anyone.
In other words, the Vetus Ordo Mass is demonstrably superior in every way but one: it does not bring more Jesus down from Heaven to be consumed by sinners. (If you believe it does, then you may stop reading right now, because we're probably not going to agree on anything.)
Like it or not, the Novus Ordo is the typical Mass of the Catholic Church; the Vetus Ordo being a tiny exception for people in cities that may have one available. To the Bear's knowledge, there is not one for the southern third, at least, of the state of Illinois -- which is a pretty big state -- outside of the metro east area (or immediately across the Mississippi River in St. Louis).
Going on about how awful the Novus Ordo Mass is writes off the vast majority of Catholics.
The Bear thinks it would be great if the Catholic Church would return to her glory days: Latin Mass, tens of thousands attending public rosary rallies with government officials, big families and no shortage of priests, all brick by magical brick.
But that's not going to happen.
In isolated traditionalist enclaves, things probably look pretty good. It must seem like a simple matter of just getting more Latin Masses going in the hinterlands, if traditionalists ever think of the hinterlands. It is easier to get a "critical mass" when you have the population of a Metropolitan Statistical Area to draw from. It is a much different story outside the big cities.
But this raises another point. Most people in the hinterlands don't want Latin Masses. They like their "participation," their "friendliness," and Father's non-challenging homilies. The Bear believes there is something a bit elitist in turning your nose up at these sentiments, although ideally they should be gently improved over time whenever possible. Elitist, and, the word must be used: divisive.
Where is the humility St. Paul demands of the more mature or secure Christian in the matter of externals? God forbid anyone should read anything written by the Bear that damages his faith, and would not criticism of the ordinary celebration of the Church's Mass run that risk?
The Bear believes the way to have a better Church is to make whatever parish God has planted you in better. If you go to an FSSP or Institute of Christ the King church, maybe you don't have much work to do other than polishing an already well-oiled machine. If you're in a Novus Ordo parish, maybe you have a lot more work to do, starting with a crumbling foundation. And maybe the mission is not to try to generate support for a Latin Mass for an elite group (good luck), but to be the one RCIA instructor that actually teaches the faith, or the voice of sanity on the parish council.
(It's kind of fun, really, like being a secret agent.)
That's not much, true. God has wisely not entrusted much into the Bear's paws. But his Novus Ordo parish is where Heaven meets Earth. Shall the Bear flee (again) from his post? Never. He will do what little he can do, without criticizing anybody else's Catholicism.
So sing the praises of traditionalism. But don't be surprised if the Bear turns a deaf ear when the humble Novus Ordo Mass per se is criticized. (We're not talking about silly abuses like puppets or clowns; that's fair game.)
The Bear is conservative when it comes to doctrine, but will go to his despised Novus Ordo Mass. It is still too good for a sinner such as he.
Quick commercial for free, no-strings-attached gift of a professionally produced audio book of Judging Angels, Chapter 1: Last Things, read...
NOTE: As for those questioning the wisdom of this post, has it not proved that the only argument is between those who view the Pope in the...
Respect me, or else. A Common-Sense Response to the Complex Question of Respect First of all, the Bear acknowledges that this is a...
The Church and Holy Scripture. Objection: Who are You to Know Better than the Pope? The matter of respect due the Pope by bloggers ...